"Don't Call Me a Monster": The Nicole Nachtman Case

Listen to this episode from TRUE CRIME with Bratterstein on Spotify. As always, thank you for hanging out and remembering Robert Dienes and Myriam Dienes with me today.In August 2015, the quiet suburb of Carrollwood, Florida, was shaken by a brutal double murder. Twenty-one-year-old college student Nicole Nachtman shot and killed her stepfather, Robert Dienes, inside their family home and hours later, ambushed her own mother, Myriam Dienes, in the driveway.What could drive a daughter to such violence? Prosecutors argued cold-blooded murder. The defense claimed years of emotional abuse had pushed Nicole into a psychological collapse, trapped between ending her own life, or ending her mother’s.In this episode, we dive deep into the chilling details of the Nachtman case. From the harrowing 911 calls, to Nicole’s haunting confession to her brother, to the high-stakes courtroom battle over battered child syndrome, this story reveals the dark complexity of family trauma, mental illness, and murder.Nicole Nachtman was found guilty on two counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.