The Debt Detox That Could Kill Us

Listen to this episode from Milkshakes, Markets & Madness Podcast by Brent Johnson on Spotify. The Shutdown Showdown: Why Politicians Can’t Stop SpendingPicture this: The lights flicker out in Washington, D.C., as lawmakers bicker over the next big spending bill. One side screams about fiscal responsibility, the other about essential needs, but both agree on one thing…they love doling out dollars. This week’s government shutdown isn’t just political theater…it’s a spotlight on America’s addiction to spending. With budget deficits ballooning and the national debt ticking like a time bomb, conversations are heating up about what all this means for the average Joe. Yet, amid the finger-pointing, a deeper truth emerges: spending isn’t just a habit; it’s the fuel keeping the economic engine roaring.The shutdown stems from a stalled continuing resolution, a temporary fix to keep the government running. Politicians on both sides grandstand, claiming moral high ground, but the real issue is agreement on where the money goes. Taxpayers foot the bill either way, through direct taxes or the hidden costs of inflation and debt. This impasse has reignited debates on slashing expenditures to tame the beastly national debt, now towering over $35 trillion. But here’s the twist: dramatically cutting spending might not save the day…it could unleash chaos.But what if slashing spending isn’t the hero move we think it is? What hidden forces make government dollars the lifeblood of our daily grind? The Hidden Engine: How Government Dollars Power Your WalletImagine the economy as a massive river, with cash flowing like water through businesses, jobs, and your bank account. Now, picture the government as the primary dam operator, releasing floods of money that keep everything afloat. When politicians spend big…on infrastructure, defense, or social programs…they’re not just writing checks…they’re injecting vitality into the system. This cash cascades into private hands, sparking commerce, creating jobs, and propping up industries.Take the COVID-19 lockdown as a stark example. When businesses shuttered and cash flow froze, the economy teetered on depression’s edge. Massive government outlays…stimulus checks, loans, and aid…offset the standstill, averting total collapse. Without that intervention, unemployment would have skyrocketed, supply chains crumbled, and everyday life ground to a halt. Sure, some argue we should’ve let the chips fall for a “natural” reset, but the reality? A frozen economy means lost livelihoods for millions.This isn’t advocacy for endless pork-barrel projects…it’s recognition of the system’s blueprint. Government spending doesn’t just fill potholes or fund schools…it circulates money that enables private transactions. Pull the plug abruptly, and you’d see a contraction: fewer dollars chasing goods, soaring costs in some sectors, plummeting in others, and widespread job losses. Transitioning to a “hard money” system, like one backed by gold or crypto, sounds appealing in theory, but the shift? It’d be like ripping off a Band-Aid on a gaping wound…painful, messy, and potentially catastrophic.Ever wonder why paying off the national debt might trigger the very crisis we’re trying to avoid? Let’s peel back the layers on what that mountain of IOUs really represents. Debt Demystified: It’s Not What You ThinkForget the household budget analogy…the national debt isn’t like your credit card bill. Governments aren’t families scrimping to pay off loans; they’re the issuers of the currency itself. In today’s fiat system, those greenbacks (or their digital twins) don’t sprout from trees or mines; they’re created by the state, spent into circulation, and partially clawed back via taxes. The debt? It’s essentially the portion of spending that hasn’t been taxed away yet.This explains why the debt has swelled to astronomical heights without immediate Armageddon. Warnings about fiscal doom date back decades…think pieces from the 1990s and early 2000s fretted over unsustainable growth, yet here we stand, with the pile even higher. Bubbles like the dot-com bust, the 2008 financial crisis, and COVID should’ve been the end, right? Wrong. The system endures because the goal isn’t repayment…it’s servicing the interest while keeping the wheels turning.As rates rise, debt servicing bites harder into budgets, squeezing other priorities. But the U.S. holds aces: global demand for dollars and Treasuries makes it a relative safe haven. Compared to other nations, America’s fiscal position isn’t as precarious…it’s got advantages in reserve status, innovation, and military might that buffer against outright failure. This relativity game means the debt can balloon further than naysayers predict, consequences simmering rather than exploding.If the system is rigged to grow or die, how long can this balloon keep inflating? And what happens if we try to pop it on purpose? The Payoff Paradox: Why Erasing Debt Could Erase ProsperityHere’s the counterintuitive bombshell: aggressively paying down the national debt could spark the meltdown many fear from inaction. In a debt-based monetary setup, growth is exponential…borrow more to expand, or watch it implode. Whether you let deficits run wild or clamp down hard, the endpoint is similar: a crash. The difference? Timing.Most money isn’t printed physically; it’s loaned into existence through leverage, backed by collateral like U.S. Treasuries…the very embodiment of national debt. Wipe out the debt, and you erase that collateral, collapsing the leverage pyramid. Banks couldn’t extend credit, liquidity dries up, and the economy contracts violently. Jobs vanish, homes foreclose, and quality of life tanks. It’s not about defending waste… it’s acknowledging that dismantling the system mid-flight guarantees turbulence.Initiatives to “cut the fat” and shrink the debt sound noble, but they’d mirror the chaos of unchecked borrowing…just faster. The black hole of exponential debt sucks everything in eventually; escaping it isn’t about good intentions from politicians. It’s baked into the design. A fresh start might emerge from the rubble, but the transition? Pure hell…lost savings, disrupted supply chains, and societal upheaval.In a world where money is loaned into existence, what happens when the collateral vanishes? And who really pulls the strings when push comes to shove? The Button We’d All Push: Saving Ourselves at Any CostGovernments aren’t faceless machines…they’re run by people who, like us, prioritize survival. When the system wobbles, they act…not out of altruism, but to maintain power. Step aside and let it crumble? They’d be out of jobs, replaced in the fallout. Most citizens, despite grumbling about big government, crave that safety net in crises. During COVID, how many grabbed stimulus checks, PPP loans, or unemployment benefits? The vast majority, even those decrying the system.If you could save your family from ruin by pushing a button that harms others, would you? That’s the essence of bailouts and spending sprees…they protect the many (or the connected) at others’ expense. Central bankers hit “print,” politicians greenlight rescues, all to avert systemic failure. It’s not pretty, but it’s human nature amplified.This mindset explains why reforms stall: change demands sacrifice, and few volunteer. The system persists because it benefits enough players to keep chugging, even as inequalities widen.With markets at all-time highs, is a storm brewing just beyond the horizon? What if the rally we’ve cheered is hiding cracks ready to widen? Market Mirage: Why the Rally Might Be a Setup for a FallMarkets have defied gravity this year, shrugging off warnings of a third-quarter correction. Indicators screamed pullback…overbought conditions, potential catalysts like economic data releases…but it never materialized. As October dawns, that prediction flops, leaving portfolios lighter on hedges that didn’t pay off. Yet, this isn’t a crash call…it’s a nod to needed breathing room after relentless gains.The shutdown plays spoiler, delaying key data drops on jobs and inflation. Without those triggers, volatility simmers. Still, a correction feels overdue…the longer the delay, the steeper the potential drop. Historical analogs paint a mixed picture: some show melt-ups continuing, others sharp reversals akin to 2007-2008. On average, markets dip short-term but climb longer out, with volatility as the constant.From early 2022 to mid-April 2025, equities flatlined despite wild swings. Then came the surge…magnificent, but concentrated in tech behemoths. Calling dips in 2024 paid off; missing this leg hurts. But persistence without pause raises crash odds, though that’s not the base case. Equities could soar further in coming years, but prudence dictates caution now.As economic data piles up and global tensions rise, could October surprise us all? What undercurrents are fueling this froth? Warning Signs: Froth, Valuations, and the Infinite Money GlitchDig into the indicators, and red flags wave. Valuations stretch beyond dot-com peaks, with over 50% of market cap in tech stocks…passive flows amplify swings. Semiconductor charts bump long-term trendlines, hinting at exhaustion. Leading economic indexes turned south months ago, yet stocks ignore them, a divergence that historically resolves downward.Then there’s the “infinite money glitch”: AI firms pledge billions they don’t have to cloud providers, who buy chips from GPU giants, who invest back in AI. It’s a hype loop, meme-fueled and fragile. Call option volumes scream bull market tops, not bear bottoms. Channels dating to 2008 test upper bounds, teasing breakthroughs or breakdowns.Geopolitical sparks add fuel: U.S. military buildup in Puerto Rico, confrontations with Venezuelan vessels, and declarations against Latin American cartels signal escalating conflicts. This isn’t isolated…expect spillovers into neighboring nations, breeding market jitters.But amidst the chaos, where’s the smart money flowing? Hint: It’s all about the irresistible pull of American assets. The Dollar Milkshake: Sucking In Global CapitalForeign holdings of U.S. equities just hit records, embodying the “dollar milkshake theory”…America’s yard draws global capital like a thick shake through a straw. Despite April’s wobble, inflows reversed, powering the rally. The dollar’s dominance, Treasuries’ safety, and innovation edge make the U.S. the go-to haven.When corrections hit, foreigners might yank funds, as in past dips, but the trend persists: capital floods in, buoying markets. This resilience underpins why fiscal woes haven’t imploded yet…America’s advantages buy time. Deficits and debt grow, but so does the economy, outpacing peers.Yet, this isn’t eternal. The system demands growth; stagnation invites trouble. Watch for delayed data dumps in November…they could jolt markets. In the interim, balance upside exposure with hedges. The ride’s thrilling, but seatbelts advised.In the end, America’s fiscal saga is a high-stakes game of chicken with reality. Spending sustains, debt endures, markets tease…but for how much longer? The answers lie in the flows, the data, and the unyielding human drive to push that button when it counts. Stay vigilant; the next chapter could rewrite the rules. Join the Santiago Capital Research CommunityAt Santiago Capital Research, we help investors make sense of global markets…where capital flows, policy shifts, and geopolitical moves converge to shape opportunity.Our mission is simple: to help you see the world the way professional macro investors do.Each week, we publish The Macro Pilgrim’s Ledger, a data-rich summary that walks you through the week that was, the week ahead, and the forces moving markets—delivered straight to your inbox every Sunday evening. Start FreeGet a taste of our research by subscribing to free previews on Substack, including excerpts from our weekly ledger and market commentary and a full article breakdown of our weekly podcast…Milkshakes, Markets & Madness.👉 Subscribe to free articles on SubstackGo Deeper – For Serious InvestorsUpgrade to our Annual or Monthly mid-tier plan for full access to The Macro Pilgrim’s Ledger and all 3-4 in-depth articles each month exploring the intersection of capital markets, geopolitics, and the madness of crowds.You’ll get clarity, charts, and actionable insights to navigate the world’s most complex investment landscape.👉 Unlock full access with the Annual or Monthly planFor Professionals – Santiago Capital ProIf you manage money, allocate capital, or simply want to think like the pros…Santiago Capital Pro is for you.Pro members receive everything from the Annual plan plus:* Deep-dive institutional research.* Two live Q&A sessions per month with Brent Johnson.* Access to proprietary data and professional-grade insights.👉 Join Santiago Capital ProThe global financial system is shifting.Understanding those shifts isn’t optional…it’s how wealth survives the transition.Start free. Upgrade when ready. Invest intelligently. To hear more, visit research.santiagocapital.com