The Gilgo Beach Murders: Did a Serial Killer Hide in Plain Sight for 13 Years?

Listen to this episode from Motives and Malice with Brooke Makenna on Spotify. In this chilling episode of Motives and Malice with Brooke Makenna, Brooke dives deep into the shocking Gilgo Beach murders—an infamous cold case that haunted New York for over a decade. After 13 years, authorities finally arrested a suspected serial killer linked to the “Gilgo 4.” How did he evade capture for so long? How many victims were there? And what really happened to Shannon Gilbert, whose desperate 911 call sparked it all? Brooke unravels the disturbing timeline, hidden clues, and terrifying truths behind one of the most haunting cases in recent history.