The Licari Family Catfish Scandal: The High School Lie That Destroyed Lives

Listen to this episode from Crime Report with Christina Randall on Spotify. In this powerful episode of Crime Report with Christina Randall, Christina unravels the disturbing true story behind Netflix’s Unknown Caller—the shocking catfishing scheme that targeted the Licari family. What seemed like ordinary high school drama spiraled into a web of deception, manipulation, and heartbreak that tore an entire community apart. How did one person manage to fool everyone—and why? Christina explores the emotional aftermath, the search for justice, and the lasting scars left behind. This haunting case will make you question just how well you really know the people around you.