The Neighbor’s Secret: The Disappearance of Jimmy Schaeffer | True Crime & Wine With Sherrilyn Dale

Listen to this episode from True Crime and Wine with Sherrilyn Dale on Spotify. In this gripping episode of True Crime & Wine With Sherrilyn Dale, Sherrilyn unravels the chilling disappearance of Jimmy Schaeffer—a devoted father and trusted limo driver who vanished without a trace after a routine trip. Was Jimmy running from mounting financial troubles, or did betrayal come from right next door? As investigators dig deeper, unsettling ties emerge with his neighbor, Angela Stoldt, exposing secrets that shattered a community’s sense of safety. How well do you really know your neighbors? Join Sherrilyn as she explores this twisted tale of deception, betrayal, and mystery lurking in plain sight.